Reading between the lines

 

As I work my way towards the last of Alexander Mathison's letters, it feels much like reading a suspense novel. When the dates of the letters flirted with the years around 1917 and 1918, I wondered what Alex would write about the news of the death of one of Margaret and John Thomson's sons, Tom. Surely they must have told him about this unexpected death.

But did they? Tom's disappearance in early July of 1917 and the discovery of his body on July 16 of that year* are known facts as the mystery of Tom Thomson's death has been widely written about. A scan of the information extracted from Alex' letters in 1917 and 1918 revealed no mention of the loss of his nephew, Tom.

I was intrigued. Were the Thomson's keeping Alex in the dark? Perhaps they didn't want to send him information about his nephew in a letter. Maybe Alex had never met Tom or the family didn't like to talk about that particular son. There is no mention in any of the letters I have read so far about this one of Alex' nephews, although George and Henry's names do appears as nephews Alex corresponded with. Could it be that Alex and Tom did not get along or just that Tom was not a letter writer?

Piecing together the story with only one half of the correspondence results in a lot of speculation. It also looks like I need to bring in other resources to make sense of the letters I am reading.

Sources:

*Little, John. Who Killed Tom Thomson? The Truth about the Murder of One of the 20^th Century’s Most Famous Artists. Skyhorse Publishing, New York 2018.

From letters to research

 

It was a surprise when Alexander Matheson's letters jumped from 1896 to 1916. It signaled a change from the initial correspondence in which he took delight in exchanging news with the relatives he had lost for so long. In the later letter, he wrote about the 20 years they had been in touch and mentions that he visited them three times. I hope for his sake that travel from Letcher, South Dakota to Owen Sound, Ontario had become easier during that time. In the letter leading up to his first visit, he wrote that his route would go through Chicago and take him 2 or 3 days. That first visit happened in January. Not a great time of year for travel in Ontario but, at least the first time he made the journey, Alexander was a farmer so the winter was when he had the time to visit.

I'm still extracting the information from his letters but what I've read so far has deepened my curiosity about Alexander Matheson and the times in which he lived. He was a man who travelled far and lived through interesting historical times. There are places, events and people mentioned in his letters that I want to know more about. I also want to get a better feel for the background; the history of the places he lived in and wrote about and the family connections he mentions, so I need a plan.

While I continue the extraction process, I need to pinpoint items in his letters that need further research. Not only will this be research to find further information about places and events but it will also require delving into the family tree to find out where the people he has mentioned fit in. Perhaps some of them are part of that group that genealogical researchers advise that we look into, the FAN Club, (family, associates and neighbours), but others may actually fit into the Mathison family tree. It looks like this is going to be a multifaceted project.  

Delving deeper into letters from the past

 

The extraction of information from Alexander Matheson's letters is going slowly. When I wrote about pulling them out of their dusty confines I wasn't sure how many letters there were. I imagined a few missives written to his sister after they first made contact after 40 years. The few were actually nineteen. That means there's a lot of information to extract.

His sister, Margaret was not his only correspondent. He also wrote to her husband, John Thomson. Alexander also indicated that he wrote to some of Margaret and John's sons, but those letters have not survived. As the sons were out of their parents' home at that point, it's no surprise they didn't preserve the correspondence from their long lost uncle. The girls, Margaret and John's daughters, also exchanged letters with him.

As with all the other correspondence only Alexander's letters were preserved. But those to the girls of the family are frustrating. He addresses them to "My Dear Niece". That would be fine if he only had one niece but that was not the case. Margaret and John Thomson had 10 children, 4 girls and 6 boys,* so was he addressing Elizabeth, Louisa, Minnie or Margaret, also known as Peggie, when he wrote the letters to his dear niece? They were also not the only nieces attached to the Thomson household. Charlotte or Lottie Tripp had also lived with the Thomsons for a time. She was also his niece, the daughter of his deceased sister, Kate.

By the time Alexander Matheson got in touch with his family in Canada again, a lot had happened in all of their lives including births and deaths. Helpfully, Alexander reacted by citing some of the details of what he had been told while answering his relative's queries which helps in piecing together the story. I'm about halfway through the correspondence, extracting details as I go. I know there will be plenty of research to spin off from the information covered and I am looking forward to finding out more about the Thomsons and Mathesons and Alexander's life. 

Sources:

*Littlefield, Angie Tom Thomson’s Fine Kettle of Friends: biography, history, art and food. Angielittlefield.com/books.html p11

Rediscovering genealogical treasure

 

                                                   Letter from Alexander Matheson to his sister Margaret Thomson 

It was a story that captured my attention. A young man going off to seek his fortune after his family was devastated by the loss of one of their members, the wife and mother. Setting off to seek his place in the world was a time honoured rite of passage; coming back to find the family gone not how the scenario normally played out.

But how do I know what the young man, Alexander Mathison, did after that? It's in the copies of his letters which I have. Letters which he wrote to his sister Margaret when they finally connected again in 1895 after 40 years. They had a lot of catching up to do.

I pulled the letters out to see if there was anything written about my great grandmother, Lottie Tripp, as she was part of this Mathison clan. Her name appeared but so did those of other people. Margaret must have asked Alexander about what he remember of their family background hoping that as the eldest child he knew more. There are names to follow up on and explanations of family connections which require careful interpretation.

I've only skimmed the first letter so far. There are others. It makes me wonder what other nuggets of information I will find. It also reminds me that I have spent years amassing documents about my ancestors. I'm good at the finding part, not so good at the filing part and, obviously, not that great with the analysis and planning for next steps part. I need to remedy that because, as I look through my amassed information for stories to tell, there is sure to be more untapped genealogical treasure.